The Ideal Big East
29-Aug-03
This is a little off topic (from the usual politics) and I am a bit biased (being a Syracuse alumnus), however, let's take a look at the dire situation in the Big East and propose a fix.
First, let's pretend -- that when Penn State asked to join the Big East back in the early nineties and the Big East (i.e., Mike Tranghese) said, "No, we are not looking to expand at this time," and Penn State subsequently becomes the eleventh member of the Big Ten -- that all didn't happen. So Penn State is in.
We know University of Miami (Florida) and Virginia Tech are gone. That helps with basketball by eliminating dead weight but kills football. VaTech is basically a two-year vocational school anyway. (Obviously I am not biased about the McNabb-Vick situation.)
So in football we look like this: Syracuse, Boston College, Pittsburgh, West Virginia, Connecticut, Rutgers (with Temple exiting to the obscurity of Division 1-AA), and the newly acquired Penn State. That makes 7 schools -- we need a few more.
The basketball division right now can be broken down into three categories:
(1) Football schools: Syracuse, Connecticut, Boston College, Pittsburgh, West Virginia, Rutgers, and (all new) Penn State;
(2) Basketball only schools: Providence, Villanova, St. John's, Seton Hall, and Georgetown; and
(3) Notre Dame.
That makes 13 schools in the Big East -- 7 football, 5 basketball only, and Notre Dame.
Eventually Notre Dame caves in and decides to become a full member; now we have 8 football schools but let's not stop there. The Big East then steals Louisville and Cincinatti from Conference USA and Xavier as a basketball only school from the Atlantic 10. Finally -- 16 teams: 10 football, 6 basketball only.
The conference will be split into two divisions, North and South, for football:
North -- Syracuse, B.C., Notre Dame, Connecticut, and Rutgers;
South -- Pitt, Penn State, West Va., Louisville, and Cincinatti.
The conference will be split into two divisions, East and West, for basketball:
East -- Connecticut, Boston College, Providence, Villanova, St. John's, Rutgers, Georgetown, and Seton Hall;
West -- Syracuse, Pittsburgh, Notre Dame, West Virginia, Louisville, Cincinatti, and Xavier.
With this line-up, the Big East continues to be the most dominant top-down basketball conference and becomes a balanced football conference.
Now for this to happen...
