I wanted to follow-up on what I consider my most thoughtful blogpost ever, one in which I had discussed my feelings upon discovering my dentist's suicide. I would like to clarify a few things...
(a) I am a supporter of legalized euthansia. I feel that any "right to life" in our law also suggests a "right to end life" as well. The first time I discussed this in length was as a senior in high school (way back in '98) -- I included a clip of the x-files Simpsons episode during my presentation. (Conclusion: Simpsons clips will always garner attention.) And on a further point, conservative arguments that interpret the Constitution as a so-called Christian document and purport that abortion, euthanasia, etc., should be illegal, but that the death penalty should be practiced, and practiced widely, despite the always-present possibility that an innocent person's life may be ended, are ridiculous and hypocritical.
(b) Suicide is illegal, almost universally, and maybe it should be. Because, as you think about it, suicide really is a type of homicide, right? (It doesn't really matter anyway, the criminal in this case is deceased, if successful, and I don't think the victim will be pressing any charges. But, maybe the victim's family would.) Anyway... should assisting a person's suicide be illegal as well? If you knew that a person may commit suicide, but did not act, should you be liable? Should you be considered a "criminal?" I do not necessarily think so. (Imagine being jailed after an unsuccessful suicide attempt... talk about depression.)
(c) I feel that prison inmates should be given the opportunity to commit suicide (or be allowed to give the state permission to assist in their suicide) in the case of "prison for life." (This may be construed as the death penalty, which I am against, however, especially if the State takes a proactive role in the process. In the end, probably not a good idea, but I do feel that these inmates should have the choice.)
(d) I feel that any, and almost all, efforts to physically stop suicides, including efforts by evangelicals to build a suicide barrier on the Golden Gate Bridge, are silly and will end up being fruitless. If someone would like to jump off the Golden Gate Bridge, they will. And if a wall stops them, they will proceed to the Bay Bridge, or a cliff in Marin, etc.
(e) And finally, I respect people's wishes, my dentist included. Although the news hit me, caught me off guard and left we confused, I have no idea what this man was thinking, and for how long. All I can do now is understand the reality and respect him in death.